whatisgithub

What is draft-review-kit?

everyinc/draft-review-kit — explained in plain English

Analysis updated 2026-05-18

61Audience · writerComplexity · 1/5Setup · easy

In one sentence

A set of Markdown-based AI editorial review skills for Claude Code or Codex that give writing drafts distinct, targeted rounds of feedback.

Mindmap

mindmap
  root((repo))
    What it does
      Editorial review skills
      Plugs into AI writing tools
      Not a writing generator
    Tech stack
      Markdown files
      Claude Code
      Codex
    Use cases
      Structural review
      Reader response testing
      Craft lens feedback
    Audience
      Writers
      Editors
    Reviewer types
      Big picture reviewers
      Reader response reviewers
      Craft lens reviewers

Code map

Detail Auto

An interactive map of this repo's files and how they connect — its source is parsed live in your browser. Click Visualize to build it.

filefunction / class

What do people build with it?

USE CASE 1

Run a structural review on a draft to check argument, pacing, and logic gaps before publishing.

USE CASE 2

Simulate harsh, non-expert, and jargon-sensitive readers to catch different weaknesses.

USE CASE 3

Apply craft-lens reviewers for suspense, pacing, humor, or word economy.

USE CASE 4

Fork and edit the Markdown skill files to match your own editorial standards.

What is it built with?

MarkdownClaude CodeCodex

How does it compare?

everyinc/draft-review-kit12britz/awesome-free-models1utkarsh1/mcp-stdio-guard
Stars616161
LanguageJavaScript
Setup difficultyeasyeasyeasy
Complexity1/51/52/5
Audiencewritervibe coderdeveloper

Figures from each repo's GitHub metadata at analysis time.

How do you get it running?

Difficulty · easy Time to first run · 5min
The README does not state a license.

So what is it?

Draft Review Kit is a collection of editorial review skills you can plug into AI writing environments like Claude Code or Codex. It is not a writing generator. Once you have a draft on the page, these skills act as a small panel of reviewers, each with a specific and distinct job, so you can run the kind of pressure you need rather than getting one generic round of AI feedback. The reviewers fall into four groups. Big-picture reviewers look at argument, structure, and stakes: one called dev-edit checks whether the piece holds together and pays off, another called guardrails scans for logic gaps, unsupported claims, and the kinds of patterned phrasing that tend to creep into AI-assisted writing. Two others, panel and debate, either synthesize feedback from multiple angles or have reviewers argue with each other until the tensions become clear. Reader-response reviewers simulate specific audience types. One reads as harshly as possible and attacks weak claims. One reads as a caring non-expert and flags anything that assumes too much. A third spots jargon, hand-waving, and steps the reader was expected to follow without explanation. Craft-lens reviewers channel the aesthetic priorities of particular writers or filmmakers: one checks for suspense and visible tension in the writing, one looks at pacing and forward motion, others look for humor, specificity, or unnecessary words. A final line-edit reviewer does a sentence-level pass and summarizes what it changed. The suggested workflow is sequential: structure first, reader-response testing second, craft lens third, a guardrails pass before publication, and a line edit last. Each skill is a plain Markdown file, which means it can be adapted to any AI environment that supports reusable instructions, not just the two it ships with. The project can also be forked and modified to match your own editorial standards.

Copy-paste prompts

Prompt 1
Run the guardrails reviewer skill on this draft and list any unsupported claims.
Prompt 2
Walk my draft through the suggested review order: structure, reader response, craft lens, then line edit.
Prompt 3
Adapt one of these reviewer skills into a custom Markdown file for my own writing style.
Prompt 4
Simulate the harsh-reader review skill on this paragraph and tell me what it would attack.

Frequently asked questions

What is draft-review-kit?

A set of Markdown-based AI editorial review skills for Claude Code or Codex that give writing drafts distinct, targeted rounds of feedback.

What license does draft-review-kit use?

The README does not state a license.

How hard is draft-review-kit to set up?

Setup difficulty is rated easy, with roughly 5min to a first successful run.

Who is draft-review-kit for?

Mainly writer.

Open on GitHub → Ask about another repo

This repo across BitVibe Labs

Verify against the repo before relying on details.